• Custoslibera@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    Sentience may not necessarily mean moral relevance.

    For example to be a member of a moral community, which are groups of people who agree to uphold and undertake certain actions with a shared belief of what is good or bad, requires more than just sentience.

    For me personally the ability to hold someone accountable for their actions in some way is an important component of moral community membership.

    Animals are not held accountable in the same fashion as humans and so it could be argued they don’t deserve membership in our moral community.

    If that’s the case then they have some kind of diminished moral standing.

    You may then argue that a fetus or comatose person also has diminished moral standing so what obligation do we have in those instances?

    One answer to that would be to hold the belief that although a fetus or comatose person is unable to have complete membership to a moral community they are impeded by other circumstances and if those impediments were removed they would be full members. A cow on the other hand will always retain the cognition of a cow, excluding it from full membership.

    • iiGxC@slrpnk.net
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      10 months ago

      by that logic, a human with severe brain damage or other severe mental illness could be excluded from the moral community. That seems like a red flag.

      What do you think about dog or chicken fights?

      • Custoslibera@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        10 months ago

        I have!

        Yes it’s an interesting thought experiment and I am guessing you believe it is relevant because you could imagine yourself as an animal and it would be a poor world if you were treated the same way as animals used for food are?

        My argument against it would be that the veil of ignorance focuses on members in the society and this isn’t extended to animals.

        • iiGxC@slrpnk.net
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          edit-2
          10 months ago

          Yes, if I were in the original position and there was a chance I could be born into a life of being treated like property with no autonomy and completely incapable of improving my lot in life, that would be unacceptable.

          From the original position it doesn’t matter how you interact with a society, if the society affects you it is relevant and worth considering from the original position. For a human-to-human example, a slaveowner could use that logic to say that slaves aren’t members of society so therefore the original position doesn’t extend to them. But it does extend to them, they are affected by the society even if they don’t get to make decisions about how it operates or interact with it freely, the society’s norms, values, and what it accepts heavily influences their life and experience of the world, and so they are very much worth considering from the original position. From the original position, there’s a chance you could be the one born under the heel of societies boot, and that society might not view you as part of their society and use that to justify your abuse and exploitation. All the more if you’re not human and can’t advocate and fight strategically for your own freedom the way humans can

          Edit: obviously a human slave, once freed, would be able to participate in society in a way that a nonhuman animal couldn’t, but even then there are humans with severe brain damage or severe mental illness who would not be able to participate in society much. From the original position they matter too, even if they can’t participate in society or be held responsible for things

      • commie@lemmy.dbzer0.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        10 months ago

        The veil of ignorance only teaches you about yourself. there is not a universal lesson to be learned from it.