• 2 Posts
  • 3.28K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 3rd, 2023

help-circle

  • On the one hand, it’s fun to fuck with players. “So you enter the room? Cross the threshold of your own free will? Ok who’s wearing metal?” when none of that matters, but you write it down anyway.

    On the other, sometimes I’ve had to be like “ok guys seriously there’s no traps here. Put away the ten foot pole and chickens let’s just move along”






  • That means that a goblin with a dagger is a real threat, especially if he has friends, because you might be able to hit his buddies with a 4 on the die, but he could definitely work together with his friends to get a crit on you. And if he has a dagger with runes on it, or poison, or something like that, your day just got really bad.

    That sounds interesting, that weak monsters can work together to be mechanically threatening. I’ve heard about PF2e having more teamwork, but I’m not familiar enough with the system to comment on it. I have noticed that D&D tends to be very much “everyone does their thing on their turn, and then spaces out until they get attacked or are up again”.

    I like how Fate lets anyone “create an advantage”, so your party face that can’t throw a punch can use their “Bravado” skill (or whatever) to distract the enemy, so someone can use that to land a big hit. I imagine PF2e has stuff like that


  • My character has grown in power, why is the rat from the beginning still able to down me?

    I read an article online somewhere about bounded accuracy, and it brought a question like that as a litmus test for if you like the idea. Should a novice archer, no matter how lucky they are, be able to shoot the ominous black knight? For a scratch? Or a lucky hit in the throat?

    D&D 3e says no. You can only hit them on a natural 20. I think PF2e also says no in the same way.

    D&D 5e tried to say yes, the archer should be able to hit the knight. The knight’s armor is probably ~22, and the archer is rolling at +5, so there’s decent odds. But he certainly won’t be able to kill him, because HP is what scales up with power.

    Other systems are more deadly.

    Personally, I don’t like the “these goblins can’t even touch me anymore” mode that much. I prefer less superhero heroics, where a goblin with a knife can be a real threat




  • How often do pathfinder games do the thing like “The soldiers in the first area attack at +4, but these basically identical soldiers two plot beats later attack at +12, because you’re higher level and I want the math to be challenging”? Because I’ve always disliked that in games. That’s more of a video game trope, but I’ve seen it leak into tabletop games before. I liked the idea of bounded accuracy, and how a goblin is always a goblin. You don’t need to make mega-goblins to fight the higher level party, because even the little ones can still hit and wear you down.










  • Meetup.com has been around for years. I think it was founded after 9/11 and the owner was like “what am i doing with my life? i want to meet people”. I knew a bunch of people who worked there, and they were always sad that such a good idea wasn’t managed better. I go to one local meetup for board games, and I used to go to another one that was just “brooklyn outdoor hangouts”.

    So far as I know they’re not particularly privacy invasive. They make money by charging the people running the meetups, so there’s less incentive to screw with the attending users. My friends don’t work there anymore though, so I’m not up to date on their latest.

    Another vector for finding stuff was location based. Like, looking up places and seeing what they’re offering. There’s a community center not far from me, so I looked up what kind of stuff they do. They have recreational sports, book clubs, some sort of ballroom dancing class, and more. The local library also does events. I went to a couple of those I found on their website. There are board game cafes near me that do regular events, though you often have to pay so I don’t go to them much. Prospect Park (the big park in brooklyn) does some events too, but those seem to be mostly one-off. For making friends and finding partners you want recurring encounters.

    I know bars are a cliché, but some do events you can enjoy without drinking booze. One near me does D&D nights in the back. I didn’t join but I chatted with them, and they meet on the regular. Trivia nights are popular, though I found that works better if you bring at least one existing friend to get started.

    For new york, there are also websites like https://donyc.com/free-events-nyc . I haven’t used this much, but a friend swears by it. I don’t think it’s as good for making new friends, because of a lot of the stuff is like big, impersonal, events. But your local city might have a similar publication.

    Less useful for getting started, there’s also word of mouth. A friend of mine told me about a local recreational sports league they play in. Someone else told me about a bird watching club that meets in the mornings.