I don’t read my replies

  • 124 Posts
  • 1.47K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 6th, 2023

help-circle




  • The Milligram experiment is almost as big a humbug as the Stanford prison experiment.

    When the study was run without a “scientist”, but instead a policeman or military officer, the participants who went full voltage dropped from 90+% compliance to 90+% refusal. This completely contradicts the supposed “findings” that people uncritically obey authority.

    After the war, a whole cottage industry of psychologists and philosophers tried to answer why it was that ordinary Germans could participate in horror. Simple, but wrong explanations like “humans obey authority uncritically” were in high demand.





  • According to some psycho-annalists, you don’t have an authentic self. It’s just a Russian nesting dolls of personas and identities that we show the world, but at the bottom is not our true self, but instead another mask we show ourselves.

    I’m not sure about all that, but personality, persona, identity, and self are all concepts we use to understand our consciousness. So it would be a mistake to try and reify those concepts as though they’re a real part of you like an ear or a leg.




  • I “reread” this a couple of years ago, only to discover I was reading it for the first time. Though the letter writing framing is a personal annoyance, the author drops out of that narrative style pretty quickly. Some other stuff may seem like tropes, but keep in mind that Shelley pioneered many of those tropes.

    minor spoilers below.

    The thing that stuck out to me was that the Monster was truly evil and didn’t deserve any sympathy. I know that contradicts the text of the book, but it’s true. The monster knows only pain and suffering, but it’s solution is to create another to suffer just as he has.

    In the Ice cave scene, the monster specifically requests that his “bride” be made hideous so that she’d have no other option than companionship with the monster. The doctor doubts that the “bride” can be so easily controlled. These are the only times in the book where the “bride’s” agency is considered.

    No, the monster isn’t a tragic hero, it’s a twisted incel who demands his government girlfriend.